Artificial Wisdom – Salvation Has A Price (Book Review)

What does climate change mean for the future of humanity?

Would you trust AI to save us?

Thomas Weaver, author of Artificial Wisdom has shared a magnificent techno thriller with us. Artificial Wisdom is about how far we’d go to use technology to solve the climate crisis, and at what cost, told through the story of a journalist determined to find the truth about a huge cover-up, no matter what the consequences.

Having just read this book myself, I must say I was captivated. As a huge fan of crime thrillers, this one came from a very different angle – and I loved it. Fast paced, absolutely packed with intrigue, and future technology, not to mention, an extremely important message. Political corruption, artificial intelligence and climate change are already such huge influences on our lives. This fictional future shot feels almost possible. And it’s a little scary.

Photo by Lynsey @MonsoonOfRandom

When we talk about artificial intelligence and sentience we often think of Terminator, or Battlestar Galactica. The rise of the machine against humanity. I was enthralled by the author’s use of AI as humanity’s chance of salvation. This is of course, in a worst case future dystopian world.

What scares you more? Climate change or artificial intelligence. I’m on the fence. But as Thomas Weaver brings to light in his story and reflections in interviews, our climate is just so connected. We’re all affected by the climate changes that happen in each area of our planet. Then again, we could all be so easily affected by one decision from AI too. Regardless, the race to save humanity from climate change seems to fast be running away from us. Thomas Weaver manages to highlight this in a way which entertains the reader.

Artificial Wisdom is every bit as much an enjoyable read as it is a scary future shock. The fact that Weaver’s fictional 2050 could theoretically come to pass – complete with a safe Utopia for the rich – makes it all the more captivating. Five stars.

Salvation has a Price

It’s 2050, a decade after a heatwave that killed four hundred million across the Persian Gulf, including journalist Marcus Tully’s wife. Now he must uncover the truth: was the disaster natural? Or is the weather now a weapon of genocide?

A whistleblower pulls Tully into a murder investigation at the centre of an election battle for a global dictator, with a mandate to prevent a climate apocalypse. A former US President campaigns against the first AI politician for the position, but someone is trying to sway the outcome.

Tully must convince the world to face the truth and make hard choices about the future of the species. But will humanity ultimately choose salvation over freedom, whatever the cost?

An enthralling murder mystery with a vividly realised future world, forcing readers to grapple with hard hitting questions about the climate crisis, our relationship with Artificial Intelligence and the price we’d be willing to pay, as a species, to be saved. Perfect for fans of Blake Crouch, Neal Stephenson, Philip K. Dick, Kim Stanley Robinson and RR Haywood.

Author Interview

I’d like to share a Q&A with the author, Thomas Weaver, courtesy of Literally PR.

What are some of the key themes that you explore in the book, and why did you choose to focus on them in your writing?

There are some obvious, surface-level themes, around the climate and potential of Artificial Intelligence. And there are some deeper ones, such as how easy it is to manipulate large swathes of the population through the media, social and traditional, or the ethics of creating new cities that offer greater protection, but only for an elite few. I chose to focus on all of them as the culmination of most of the things I’d spent the last few years pondering and worrying about. It was, in a way, something like therapy or catharsis to get those worries down, to twist them into worries for the characters, and to take some action (even if it is just on the written page, for now).

We all hear about artificial intelligence in the news on a regular basis, but what actually is it?

It’s probably easier to define in terms of what it isn’t. It isn’t and will likely never be sentient intelligence that works in the same way our own intelligence works, or any other biological intelligence we have some understanding of, like the Octopus. Even if we program it to simulate humanity, that will be the thin veneer on a sea of complexity. In some ways, perhaps, this is because we don’t really understand things like consciousness or the full complexity of the brain yet. In others, it’s because computers are simply better at different things than humans are.

Photo by SCREEN POST on Unsplash

Right now, it is much more of a very clever prediction tool that can spot patterns and in language, images and data, and broadly interpret the context behind natural language. Some people dismiss that as a clever autocorrect, but this technology is developing in power exponentially, and we may soon lack the capability of understanding what it’s really doing behind the scenes. Remember, a few years ago, Facebook shut down two AIs, designed to test negotiation strategies, because they created their own language to make it easier to communicate with each other. We also can’t think of AI as a single entity. Someone likened ChatGPT to a million interns waiting to do your bidding. What does that look like when you scale both capability and capacity? A billion junior executives? A trillion CEOs or, perhaps more interestingly, senior engineers?

What many highly regarded intellectuals are afraid of is the singularity, which is the point at which AI escapes any rules and restrictions we’ve put on it, like a rocket breaking from our gravity and embarking on a journey to the stars. We see this from the human perspective, partly because, in the 1950s, we decided to call it artificial intelligence and not something else: humans have always been quick to trample on any lesser being in our quest to dominate our environment. Would our creation do the same to us? Would we become like ants to it (or them)?

Or can we somehow keep control, and guide AI towards solving our current crises? The potential, if we get that right, is that it will be humanity lifting off to the stars, leaving a healed world behind it, with fusion powering our grids and natural death something we have put off for centuries to come.

Photo by Maria Teneva on Unsplash

What initially sparked your interest in exploring the intersection of artificial intelligence, political manipulation, and climate change?

The Brexit Referendum and Trump’s 2018 win were the first major influences on this story, and in particular the suspicions that fell on the Russians and their online manipulation of public opinions in both countries struck me. If it was so easy to make people believe something or vote in a certain way, by appealing to their biggest fears, with just a few hundred people in a bot farm outside Moscow… What would it be like when we actually had something sophisticated, like AI, able to understand at a much more personal level what might make us change our minds on any given issue?

My first written note on this story in September 2019 reads, “Civilisation, splitting apart in polarisation, puts their fate in an AI leader in a Brexit style referendum.” That’s not quite the story I ended up telling, but it was the roots of it.

The climate theme came later. I’d read an article about how some countries with significant land above a certain latitude (like Russia) were potential beneficiaries of climate change, as it would unlock significant resources. I started to wonder how you could truly solve something as interconnected as the climate crisis when each country was pulling towards their own priorities.

Photo by Markus Spiske on Unsplash

And finally, I was listening to the incredible Dan Carlin Hardcore History podcast called Death Throes of the Republic, on the shift of Rome from Republic to Empire. I’d listened to it multiple times, as I’m a huge fan of that period of history. That made me think of the role of the Roman dictator in consolidating power and solving crises. Wouldn’t we have to ultimately do the same at a global level?

Your novel suggests the need for a global leader, potentially an AI, to tackle the climate crisis. Could you expand on this concept and why you think individual nations might struggle to address this issue on their own?

In January, there was a story in the Washington Post about an entrepreneur who’d read Neal Stephenson’s cli-fi novel Termination Shock and got the idea of taking action himself by doing some solar geo-engineering: firing sulphur into the atmosphere to bring down the global temp. Not long afterwards, Mexico banned solar geo-engineering on their own soil after they ran some field tests there. But how could any nation really stop someone determined to take action on their own? Someone could just get on a boat and do something that, for better or worse, would affect us all for years to come, and perhaps forever.

Photo by NOAA on Unsplash

The climate is interconnected. It doesn’t respect borders, those age-old, man-made, imaginary lines that divide us and box us into the lands our ancestors claimed. If countries disagree over how we turn this crisis around, we risk becoming paralysed. At least with the ozone layer, there was one very obvious strategy to fix it: ban CFCs. 197 countries have outlawed them, and the ozone layer healed. There is no equivalent, obvious strategy to fix the climate. We need to do many things, all in parallel, and some of them run counter to our comfortable status-quo. 

I’m definitely not saying there should be a global leader. In a way, that would be the worst-case scenario. But this book is set within that scenario.

Artificial Wisdom explores some serious ethical dilemmas, particularly around manipulation and making hard choices for the greater good. How did you navigate these issues in your writing, and what messages do you hope that readers will take away?

Most of all with this book, I’m hoping that readers will take away an enjoyable read full of interesting turns and little mysteries. I was very wary of trying to preach anything. I know from being a father than preaching rarely gets a message through!

I’m also not a believer in black and white, here, or that I somehow have answers the world needs to listen to. This isn’t a book about good and evil, like some golden-age epic fantasy novel (I already have a shelf full of those). I wanted to leave people debating, arguing, disagreeing. What’s right here? I certainly don’t know. I mentioned earlier that (perhaps) it is easy to manipulate huge numbers of a population through social media, just as we once did through propaganda.

But propaganda has been used for good as well as evil. We just call them campaigns. Always wear a seatbelt. Stop smoking cigarettes. Is it large scale manipulation? Of course, it is. Where do you draw the line if you think, as a government, you know what’s best for your population? And that assumes the government are actually doing things that’s best for the population, and not just for themselves!

Was it important for you to explore these important themes through the form of fiction over non-fiction? If so, why?

I believe stories stay with us in a much more powerful way than non-fiction and become timeless. 1984 is still as relevant today as when Orwell wrote it, and has done a better job of helping us understand what a totalitarianism dystopia would be like to live in than any article or journal could hypothesise, because when you read 1984, you’re really there, in Winston Smith’s apartment or in Room 101. You’re experiencing it, and therefore you understand it at a much deeper level.

I love non-fiction, and it can influence me heavily, but I think great storytelling imprints on our psyche. It collectively inspires us or scares us, which is why it’s so important for us to share stories we love with those we love. The magic of story casts deep in the brain and takes us back to the camp-fires of our ancestors. When we hear a good story, it feels real in the same way our memories feel real, so it’s much more vivid and can have a greater impact.

Fiction, particularly science-fiction, can imagine things that are impossible today and inspire people to make that a reality.  For example, we probably can’t now imagine a future with humanoid robots where those robots aren’t rising up against humanity. That’s because countless sci-fi epic movies and books, particularly the Terminator series and the Matrix, have done an amazing job of telling that story. It’s an uphill battle for any company making humanoid robots, like Boston Dynamics, to not make people immediately think, upon seeing a video of a robot doing somersaults or being deliberately pushed over and hit with sticks, yeah, but what happens when it also has a gun?

What does the title, Artificial Wisdom, really mean?

Artificial Intelligence, as someone once wisely said, was a poor choice of words from the 1950s, and it’s defined how we decided to create it: to become something that can appear human to humans. But to make decisions we’d need to solve the climate crisis without wiping out humanity in the process will require more than intelligence, but wisdom too. Intelligence is quite cold. Wisdom, on the other hand, is about being able to intelligently grasp human nature. The inspiration was King Solomon. He was known for being of immense intelligence and a great scholar, but he’s popularly remembered for his wisdom and ability to settle disputes amongst his people.

Do you hope to write more books in the future?

Just try and stop me.

I’m on the third draft of my second book, a standalone with series potential I’m very excited about, called Futilitytown. I’m currently in a battle with the ending, and the ending is winning, but I’ve got some tricks up my sleeves it won’t see coming. I have ideas for several sequels and stories set in the same setting with other characters (not quite a spin-off, but almost).

I also have the first thirty thousand words of another book set in a space hotel, which was originally my second book, but I stalled on it. Ultimately, I have an idea there I really love, I just didn’t nail my main character, and need to rewrite what I have with someone more proactive.

If the reception to Artificial Wisdom is good, I also have an outline sitting in the drawer for a sequel. But I’ll have to be bribed with lots of good reviews if people want to find out what happens next.

And finally, what do you ultimately hope that readers will take away from Artificial Wisdom?

Hope, that we have the capability to do more than we can imagine. And restraint, that there may be some costs too high to bear.

Artificial Wisdom is available to buy in hardback and e-book from all good book stores – digital and physical. It pairs very well with a good cup of coffee.

Keep reading for more book reviews.

WANT MORE?

SIGN UP TO RECEIVE THE LATEST ECO-FRIENDLY TIPS AND IDEAS.

We don’t spam! It’s easy to unsubscribe if you change your mind.

Thanks to Literally PR for sending me a copy of this book to review. All opinions are my own.

One Comment Add yours

  1. Thank you for a great review. I’m glad it left you thinking about these things… that was very much the intention! And I’m thrilled you enjoyed it.

Leave a Reply